Protests by school students across France have been gathering force since late September, with pupils blockading hundreds of high schools and demonstrations drawing crowds that organisers say have reached into the hundreds of thousands. The unrest has not remained peaceful: hundreds of students, teachers and police officers have reportedly been injured, while thousands of people have been arrested, including an unspecified number of individuals accused of joining the disturbances from outside the school communities.
At the centre of the movement are the lycées, the French secondary schools attended by students aged roughly 15 to 18. Pupils complain of chronic staffing shortages, with teachers absent for weeks at a time and no replacements provided, as well as crumbling and poorly maintained buildings. One Paris student, Madalena, told the BBC that her classrooms had become unbearably hot during recent heatwaves, describing conditions as "boiling hot."
The list of grievances extends well beyond staffing and infrastructure. Some students object to bans on mobile phones, while others resent school days that run until 6pm, leaving little time for rest or homework once they get home. One pupil told France 2 that arriving home at 7pm made it impossible to sleep properly or complete assignments.
Another flashpoint is Parcoursup, the national online platform that assigns places in higher education. Many students regard the system as opaque and anxiety-inducing, particularly because roughly 80% of each age cohort now passes the baccalauréat, the school-leaving qualification that guarantees a university place — though not necessarily at the institution or course a student wants. That mismatch fuels fierce competition for desirable programmes and concentrates student frustration on the admissions process.
Yet the BBC's analysis suggests these grievances, while genuine, do not fully account for the scale and intensity of the movement. According to the OECD, a club of developed nations, France actually spends more per lycée student than the EU average for upper-secondary education. Teacher shortages are real, but by OECD measures they are milder than in many comparable countries, with fewer unfilled posts — although French teachers are relatively poorly paid.
Long school days are likewise a long-standing feature of French education, stemming largely from extended lunch breaks and complicated timetables rather than from an unusually short holiday calendar. Compared with other EU countries, French holidays are not especially long, so the late finish cannot easily be blamed for the current eruption. Pressure created by a competitive higher-education system is also not unique to France: across most European countries, 80% to 90% of young people complete secondary education, and the scramble for good university places generates stress elsewhere too.
Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez has described the movement as "unprecedented" in terms of the number of schools and pupils involved and the level of violence, a characterisation that points to something deeper than funding complaints alone. The scale of the protests is all the more striking given the risks participants are taking: blockading a school or university by force or threats is illegal, and it draws in police as well as vandals known in France as casseurs, leaving pupils caught up in crowd-control operations that critics say are often heavy-handed.
Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu has insisted that security forces are not under instructions to "confront high-school students," only to enforce the law. Around 500 people were arrested during unrest on Tuesday, according to the source material, underscoring the intensity of the clashes.
To understand the tactics of the pupils, analysts say one must look beyond the barricaded school gates to a distinctly French political tradition in which street power has often rivalled the power of elected institutions. Students are keenly aware of this history. In October 1990, a rape at a school in Seine-Saint-Denis, an area north of Paris that has again become a focus of unrest, triggered mass rallies over underfunding and staff shortages. The government responded by releasing the equivalent of €1.2bn (£1bn) in today's money for lycées.
In October 1998, some 500,000 pupils marched across France with similar demands, winning nearly €1bn to renovate schools and 14,000 additional staff. On several occasions, student protests have defeated government reforms, including a university overhaul in 1986 and a reduction in the youth minimum wage in 1994. Perhaps the most striking demonstration of student power came in 2006, when weeks of often violent blockades in universities and lycées forced the withdrawal of a law designed to loosen hire-and-fire rules for workers under 26, a measure that parliament had passed and then-President Jacques Chirac had signed.
French adults have shown that blockading roads can also prevail over elected officials. The gilets jaunes, or yellow vests, uprising of 2018-2019, during which shops were ransacked and government buildings attacked across the country, led the government to abandon a planned fuel tax increase and approve €10bn in additional spending. But the street does not always win: the student uprising of 1968, a heroic reference point cited by virtually every subsequent French protest movement, was ultimately brought to an end by an election.
The lycéens of today are heirs to a political culture in which demonstrators compete with elected officials to be seen as the true voice of the people. That inheritance helps explain why a dispute over staffing and school buildings has escalated into a national confrontation — and why, despite the genuine nature of the complaints, the movement's scale and volatility may owe as much to France's protest tradition as to the conditions inside its classrooms.
(0)